If you’re thinking about upgrading your heating system, you’ve probably heard a lot about heat pumps. With rising energy costs and growing interest in low-carbon heating, many homeowners are now comparing traditional gas boilers vs air source heat pumps. But are heat pumps really better, and which option is right for your home?

While the core technology works the same across the UK, the best choice often depends on your property type, insulation levels and long-term plans. For homeowners in North Yorkshire, where properties range from modern homes to older stone houses and rural buildings, understanding the differences can help you make a confident, cost-effective decision.

Let’s break down how boilers and heat pumps compare, including efficiency, costs, lifespan and suitability.

How each system works

Energy Efficiency

Heat pumps are incredibly efficient, they can deliver up to three times more energy than they use. A new A-rated boiler is around 90% efficient, but heat pumps typically reach 300 – 400% efficiency.
That means lower running costs if your home is well insulated.

Installation & Upfront Costs

  • Boiler replacement: Around £1,000 – £3,000

  • Air source heat pump installation: Around £8,000 – £14,000 (before grants).

The good news is that the Boiler Upgrade Scheme currently offers grants of up to £7,500 towards a heat pump, making them much more affordable.

Maintenance & Lifespan

Boilers usually last 10-15 years with annual servicing.
Heat pumps can last 20 years or more, and require a quick yearly check to stay efficient.

Which is best for you?

  • If you live in a well-insulated home and want long-term energy savings, a heat pump is the greener choice.
  • If your home isn’t yet well insulated or you’re on a tighter budget, a new high-efficiency boiler could be the better short-term solution.

Our engineers are fully qualified to install both gas boilers and MCS-certified heat pumps. We can assess your property and help you choose the most efficient option.

Get in touch today to discuss your options.

Boiler vs Heatpump Enquiry Form